The Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System recently published their findings from a 21 state study with over 112,000 participants on how weight loss methods affect dieter's success.
Each participant was placed into one of four categories based on the weight control method they used.
1. Increasing physical activity
2. Eating fewer calories
3. Combination of fewer calories with exercise
4. None (not trying to lose weight)
For those who were trying to lose weight, the most common weight practices were eating fewer calories without other methods (32.3% of women, 24.1% of men) and eating fewer calories with exercise (33.8% of women, 19.9% of men).
Increasing physical activity as a sole weight-loss practice was reported by 3.4% of women and 4% of men.
The last statistic on exercising without dieting is where I get lost. It's hard for me to understand how only 3% of women and 4% of men use exercise as their sole weight loss practice. Is anything wrong with this?
Yes, we are wrong. The entire weight loss industry is wrong!
It all reminds me of a slogan from a few years ago, "Simply Weight Loss." It represented a return to diet basics. And that's when it hit me, a return to diet basics is what is wrong.
Dieting is Wrong
You're too heavy and you need to lose weight. The extra pounds pushing you above your ideal weight, resulted from a chronic state of positive energy balance...eating more calories (energy) than the body needs.
This is usually followed by the question, "Why doesn't my body just get rid of the extra energy?" I totally agree. Just get rid of all that extra energy, send it on it's way. Unfortunately, the laws of thermodynamics are what mess things up.
The big stinker involves the whole idea that you can't create or destroy energy. It's constant. Since you can't simply destroy energy, you have no choice but to use the extra energy (packed into calories) or store it.
So, how does this make dieting wrong? Dieting only works in theory. In theory, dieting, which is synonymous with calorie restriction, causes total body energy to decrease in hopes of creating an energy deficit.
To make up for this deficit, the body will tap into energy stores to cover immediate needs. So, in theory, dieting causes weight loss.
Is this what occurs in dieters? Yes and no.
The Best Method for Using Stored Energy
Dieting, a.k.a. calorie restriction, slows down the resting metabolic rate, throwing the body into a state of energy conservation. This is not conducive of weight loss but instead is perfect for gaining weight.
Those dieters that do lose weight and keep it off, practice my concept of Slow & Low.
Now what? Exercise.
What is the best method for using the extra energy we didn't use in the past? Exercise. Start an exercise program first, one that centers on muscle tone and strength, then use dieting on an as needed basis to lower total body energy.
The Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System published perfect statistics. We should be using exercise as a sole weight loss method more often.
To Healthy Living!
Michael Smith, MD
Chief Medical Consultant
Diet Basics Website
Michael A. Smith, MD
Dr. Smith is the Chief Medical Consultant to Diet Basics, a content based cutting edge website dedicated to the online dieter. Dr. Smith coined the term "Diet Shock<sup>TM</sup>" and is about to release his new book on keeping weight off -- our real weight problem. Visit Dr. Smith at Diet Basics.
Other articles you may be interested in....
The Holidays and Weight Loss Dieting - Still Oxymoronic to you?
By Marjet Heitzer, Ph.D.The Plateau-proof Diet Foundation Although the holidays are a time of celebration as well as reflection, they also represent a veritable dieting nightmare. Almost as a rule, each...
What Is Safe Dieting?
Safe dieting can be great. Dieting need not conjure up images of starved people or sickening food; there is such a thing as safe dieting provided you follow some basic ground rules. You can follow a preplanned...
Why You Are Fat - Natural Weight Loss Dieting Program
Have you ever wondered why you are fat and have considered going on a weight loss dieting program? If you did, then you must know why certain food makes you fat.Most if not all of us are somewhat carbohydrate...
Diet The High-Tech Way: Fitness Club Software Provides Unparelled Tools
Everything is high tech these days. So why not go electronic with dieting and exercise too? It's the new hip way to reach your health and fitness goals.Originally, online dieting was designed to let you...
From the Teen Scene: Should You Go On A Diet?
What do the hula hoop, "high-protein diets," and wearing your clothes backwards have in common? They are all fads. Fads come and go, but when it comes to fad diets, the health effects can be permanent-especially...
Quick Ways To Lose Weight | Tips To Help You Lose 50 Pounds Or More
Setting Goals When DietingAs with most things in life, setting goals is very important when dieting. When you look at things truthfully and objectively you should notice that most of the things you've...
No More Meal Stealing, No More Diets! - Demand Dieting Experts
Weight-control charity The Weight Foundation reveals exploitative food industry tactics and announces a free web-based self-help system for problem dieters, covering the emotional, the cultural and the...
Portion Control Dieting For Fast, Easy Results
Portion Control DietingAre you the kind of person who has tried diet after diet only to find that none of them have worked for you? Either these diets are too strict, or they involve foods you don't like,...